According to the saying, the importance of doing projects by collective effort is agreed upon everyone.
According to the saying, the importance of doing projects by collective effort is agreed upon everyone. NNwbb
"Team work makes the dream work". According to the saying, the importance of doing projects by collective effort is agreed upon everyone. When it comes to the matter of evaluating members' contribution to a group activity, people are of different opinions as all groupmates should be given the same grade or otherwise. I totally disagree with the notion that it is a good fashion to evaluate all members of a group as a whole for a number of reasons, among which unfairness of the method and its discouraging effect on students are the most conspicuous ones.
The salient reason why giving all group participants the same mark is not a good method is that it may deter those who are diligent. We all know that it is likely for every single group of people to have some members who want to take advantage of others. With this in mind, provided that they know the final grade is the same for all members, regardless of their efforts, they find it as an opportunity to escape their responsibilities as they are sure there are others who may make up for them; failing that, others' score may suffer too. This is the reason why many hard-working students who try hard to get a good mark may deter from making their best in group projects as they see they can have more fun by taking less time on assignments, and their final marks might be the same. Thus, group activities that were supposed to stimulate learners, runs counter to the ways that were meant to, namely that promoting bad behaviors that may discourage them from learning their lessons.
Another reason for the view is that it is not a fair way of assessing students. The underlying reason for using grades is to differentiate various individuals by their effort. The grades sometimes play a pivotal role in the future of learners as they may not be admitted in the college they are intended to apply. What makes them more important is that applicants are selected in comparison to others, which emphasizes individual appraisal of students in even group activities. In fact, teachers should always pay attention to their efforts in a comparative way to make sure the method is fair enough; something that does not happen on the condition that they are all given the same mark.
To sum up, with the above in mind, it is not true that providing groups, not individuals, with a mark in group tasks is a good idea. It is because not only does it may deter students from working hard, but it also does not bring justice to the evaluation.
"
Team work
makes
the dream work
"
. According to the saying, the importance of doing projects by collective
effort
is
agreed
upon everyone. When it
comes
to the matter of evaluating members' contribution to a
group
activity,
people
are of
different
opinions as all
groupmates
should be
given
the same
grade
or
otherwise
. I
totally
disagree with the notion that it is a
good
fashion to evaluate all members of a
group
as a whole for a number of
reasons
, among which unfairness of the method and its discouraging effect on
students
are the most conspicuous ones.
The salient
reason
why giving all
group
participants the same
mark
is not a
good
method is that it may deter those
who
are diligent. We all know that it is likely for every single
group
of
people
to have
some
members
who
want to take advantage of others. With this in mind, provided that they know the final
grade
is the same for all members, regardless of their
efforts
, they find it as an opportunity to escape their responsibilities as they are sure there are others
who
may
make
up for them; failing that, others' score may suffer too. This is the
reason
why
many
hard
-working
students
who
try
hard
to
get
a
good
mark
may deter from making their best in
group
projects as they
see
they can have more fun by taking less time on assignments, and their final
marks
might be the same.
Thus
,
group
activities that
were supposed
to stimulate learners, runs counter to the ways that
were meant
to,
namely
that promoting
bad
behaviors that may discourage them from learning their lessons.
Another
reason
for the view is that it is not a
fair
way of assessing
students
. The underlying
reason
for using
grades
is to differentiate various individuals by their
effort
. The
grades
sometimes
play a pivotal role in the future of learners as they may not
be admitted
in the college they
are intended
to apply. What
makes
them more
important
is that applicants
are selected
in comparison
to others, which emphasizes individual appraisal of
students
in even
group
activities. In fact, teachers should always pay attention to their
efforts
in a comparative way
to
make
sure the method is
fair
enough
; something that does not happen on the condition that they are all
given
the same mark.
To sum up, with the above in mind, it is not true that providing
groups
, not individuals, with a
mark
in
group
tasks is a
good
idea
. It is
because
not
only
does it may deter
students
from working
hard
,
but
it
also
does not bring justice to the evaluation.
Do not write below this line