The poet portrays the central character in ’Disabled’ as a sad and lonely veteran who is isolated from society, painting a picture of a tragic figure swept up in the war effort.
The title ‘Disabled’ in Owen’s poem is one of the key ways in which the central character is portrayed. The adjective tells us that this man may be disabled in one or more ways, creating an image of man who is only a shadow of his former self, and setting the tone for this poem, while also telling the reader what the poem is about. The title also begins to introduce some of the major themes within the poem such as; loss, loneliness and helplessness, all of which the main character is feeling because of his disability.
Within the first stanza the poet wrote that ‘He sat in a wheeled chair, waiting for dark. ’ The use of the pronoun ‘he’ shows that the man is anonymous, but this may also be symbolic to all of the other young men who came out of the war with less than they started with, and this character may be acting as a representative for the many who lost something. The adjective ‘wheeled’ tells the reader that the man cannot walk and this brings a sense of dependency, providing a tragic image of a man who used to be independent and is now bound to a chair for the rest of his life. The phrase ‘waiting for dark’ provides another depressing image of a man who has lost so much that he can only feel better in the dark, when he is asleep, when he doesn’t have to think about his problems or acknowledge them. The adjective ‘dark’ can also mean an end to something, in the poem it is the end of the day that is approaching, but maybe he also wants his life to end.
In the second line the author uses the alliteration and plosives 'ghastly suit of grey’ to present a ghostly image of the man in a suit that matches his appearance. The adjective ‘ghastly’ signifies death and wearing a ‘ghastly suit of grey’ may also be his plea for death. The adjective ‘grey’ illustrates a dull and lifeless suit which, again, could reflect how the man is seen, dull and lifeless.
After that, the poet provides more of an image of the man who the poem is about, ‘Legless, sewn short at elbow. ’ The adjective ‘legless’ depicts how the man looks and the comma afterwards adds emphasis onto the adjective beforehand, letting the reader digest that image and feel sympathy for the man and what he has lost. The phrase ‘sewn short at elbow’ highlights another part of the man’s disability and the full stop at the end is in the middle of the line, causing a caesura which, again, adds emphasis onto the man’s disabilities, evoking feelings of sympathy from the reader. The caesura also shows how his life has been stopped partway through, just like the line.
Then, the poet writes that ‘Voices of boys rang saddening like a hymn, ’ which really underlines how sad, lonely and depressed the man is. ‘Voices of boys’ are supposed to be joyful and uplifting, about the youth having fun, but in this line they are part of the simile ‘Voices of boys rang saddening like a hymn’ which shows contrast between the ‘Voices of boys’ and the verb ‘saddening’. This may suggest that the man is sad hearing the voices of the youth playing as it reminds him of his past, what he no longer has and what he can no longer do.
In the final parts of the stanza it says that ‘Voices of play and pleasures after day, till gathering sleep mothered them from him’. The alliteration of ‘play and pleasures’ adds an emphasis on these two words, reminding the reader and the man of what he can no longer do or have. The phrase ‘till gathering sleep mothered them from him’ suggests that the children had to go home, but the final part of the phrase ‘from him’ shows that they must have had some significance to him as he considers them something that he had, as if they were his own memories about his past and his youth before his life changed.
In the second stanza it says ‘When the glow-lamps budded in the light-blue trees, ’. The verb ‘budded’ refers to the youth, and the central character's youth and the phrase ‘light-blue trees’ uses a calm and bright colour to show how his life was and how he was happy.
Later in the stanza it says ‘In the old times, before he threw away his knees. ’ The time phrase ‘In the old times’ contrasts what the central character was able to do with what he can’t now. In the second part of the line the poet uses the verb ‘threw’. This is making it seem like the narrator deliberately threw away his knees and provides the reader with a sense of wastefulness but also a large sense of regret, as if the soldier was pressured into the situation, which the reader finds out later in the poem.
To end the stanza it says that ‘All of them touch him like a queer disease. ’ The predeterminer ‘all’ is referring to everyone, not just the girls, and shows how the central character is a pariah of society, where everyone avoids him and tries to interact with him as little as possible. The phrase ‘touch him like a queer disease’ shows how he is treated, with the adjective ‘queer’ meaning abnormal in this context and provokes a sense of pathos towards the central character. The noun ‘disease’ suggests that what he has is infectious and can be spread, which could be why he is isolated as people don’t want to become what he has become.
Within the third stanza it is written that ‘He’s lost his colour very far from here’. The verb ‘lost’ brings a grim image and shows the horrors of war as one can lose lots on the battlefield and afterwards when it says ‘his colour’ the noun ‘colour’ is a reference back to the dull grey suit in the first stanza. It can also be referring to his personality, to his emotions, to himself, all lost in war.
The central part of the poem depicts the youthful naivety of the character when in the fourth stanza the narrator says that ‘Aye, that was it, to please the giddy jilts’. The narrator is showing us that the central character was impressionable and swept up in the war effort and army. The ‘giddy jilts’ are referring to girls and it could be interpreted that he is easily pressured into things.
The verse size within the fifth stanza is smaller than the rest. This could be referring to how many people thanked him or appreciated his service.
At the very end of the poem there are some rhetorical questions ‘How cold and late it is! … Why don’t they come? ’ This could be the voice of Owen, and it is like he is talking to the nurses. It shows how the central character is marginalised and outcast, with no one wanting to help him. The phrase ‘Why don’t they come and put him to bed? ’ links back to the first line, as both are suggesting death and how he is waiting for it so that his suffering can end.
Throughout the poem, the use of colour is structured around the poem, telling us about the atmosphere in the stanzas where it is mentioned. For example, ‘grey’ is used within the first stanza to provide imagery for a deathly man, while in the second stanza ‘light blue’ is used to provide a happy and bright image.
Within the title, ‘Still I Rise’ the reader can see that this poem will be written in the first person from the pronoun ‘I’. The entire phrase is a declaration and shows an image of a powerful narrator who is strong and resilient. The phrase also sets the theme for the poem, where the narrator will rise against the problems that she faces and overcome them. This is also a declaration against prejudice which Angelou experienced throughout her life.
The main character, portrayed by the first person, is the poet, Angelou, and is shown as a strong, powerful and proud woman who wants to overcome the inequalities and prejudices in the world to make it a better and more equal place.
At the end of the first stanza the narrator says ‘You may trod me in the dirt, but still, like dust, I’ll rise’. The active verb ‘trod’ brings the image of the poet being stepped on metaphorically and provides an understanding of suppression and repression but the simile afterwards ‘still, like dust, I’ll rise. ’ opposes this statement and shows that Angelou is determined to not be held back and wants to reach to the skies. The full stop at the end of the stanza also creates a pause on the verb ‘rise’ which emphasises the hopeful and successful meaning of the word and the word used with the pronoun ‘I’ reflects the positive meaning onto the author.
After this Angelou uses a simile, ‘‘Cause I walk like I’ve got oil wells pumping in my living room. ’ ‘Oil wells’ are a symbol of wealth, and at that time, white wealth. This goes against the stereotypes and shows how she is opening up new possibilities that may have been restricted for people like her. It also refers to richness, such as her richness of confidence and her richness of personality.
Angelou uses references to nature in describing how she will overcome the prejudice, “Just like moons and like suns with the certainty of tides. ” Nature is seen as something that happens, and cannot be stopped, and she is calling herself like ‘nature’ and cannot be stopped. This can also be seen through the similes “Just like moons and like suns” as ‘moons’ and ‘suns’ cannot be stopped. Angelou is also saying that she is ‘certain’ she will rise when she says “With the certainty of tides, ” which again refers to nature and how nature will rise, just like nature will act. This whole stanza portrays her confidence as strong, powerful and simple, just like nature.
Within the fourth stanza more serious and disturbing themes are spoken of with Angelou using rhetorical questions which reference to slavery. “Did you want to see me broken? Bowed head and lowered eyes? ” These rhetorical questions seem sassy and mocking as if Angelou is telling the audience that those things will never happen to her. These rhetorical questions are also criticising white people, and all that they have done to black people and slaves, by providing an image of submission in the question, which is predominantly aimed at white people who thought they were superior.
She then uses violent verbs and anaphora to talk about what people may do to her. “You may shoot me with your words, ” which reference the attitudes towards black people in her time and how they were belittled and trodden on. These first three lines are also portraying the vulnerabilities of everybody and how this violence has been used to make black people suffer. Angelou finishes off the stanza with the simile “But still, like air, I’ll rise. ” This shows how strong she is and how confident she is that she will overcome that prejudice. The structure of the stanza shows the resilience of Angelou and others like her who have suffered, and how, no matter what bad things happen, they will always rise back up and confront it, no matter how hard it is.
Within the structure of the poem there are rhetorical questions which present features of herself, “Does my sassiness upset you? ” There are another two with “haughtiness” and “sexiness”. These nouns show that Angelou is confident in herself and when she asks if they “upset you? ” She is showing that she can be whatever she wants and doesn’t have to listen to anybody else.
Within the final two stanzas she uses an AABB rhyme scheme to create a strong tempo to bring the piece to a climax while also reflecting herself as a strong and steady woman, in reference to the tempo and rhythm of the piece. Angelou has changed the structure of the Stanzas from an ABCB, to the stronger and more rhythmic AABB rhyme scheme to show how she is breaking through suppression and becoming an unstoppable force that will break through prejudice, coming out as free and equal.
At the end of the penultimate stanza she references nature again in the metaphor “I’m a black ocean, leading and wide, welling and swelling I bear in the tide. ” The “black ocean” is a way of saying that she cannot be stopped as she is an immense force and anything in her way will not affect her path towards her goal. Also the active words “leading”, “wide”, “welling” and “swelling” show all that she is doing to achieve her goal, and also how much effort she has put into this.
She ends the final stanza and the poem with anaphora of the phrase “I rise”. This emphasises what she is going to do and achieve and the repetition of the phrase reinforces the idea that she will rise above the prejudice and inequality, making her more confident about achieving her goal.
I chose these two texts because of the way they conveyed strong messages and comments about society. I chose the pieces ‘Disabled’ and ‘Still I Rise’ as they explore how extreme we, as a society, can be towards those who are different, but also how we can rise up and stop this. ‘Disabled’ evoked a feeling of sorrow within, for all of the people affected by war, while ‘Still I Rise’ showed me a fiery intent to make the world a better place. Although there were other pieces of work such as ‘The Bright Lights of Sarajevo’ which showed the positivity of society and how we can overcome hardship, ‘Out, Out -’ which showed how we have become almost numb to violence and death in the media and ‘The Necklace’ which shows how materialistic desires have taken over society.
‘Disabled’ shows how we treat those who have given their life for us and that society will only accept those deemed acceptable, otherwise they shall be cast out. It is written in the third person in the perspective of an unknown soldier who served in World War One and lost his limbs and “colour” there. It talks about after the war when he is outcast for his condition and about how he gave up his life for his country.
In contrast ‘Still I Rise’ has a message of hope and confidence in the future that everybody will be equal. It is about the writer, Maya Angelou, and is set in a time of great racism and inequality in America. The poem talks about Angelou, her qualities which she is proud of, and how she will overcome societal norms and become a free and equal black woman who can stand up for herself to form a better place for people suffering from prejudice.
The
poet
portrays the
central
character
in
’Disabled’
as a sad and lonely veteran
who
is isolated
from
society
, painting a picture of a tragic figure swept up in the
war
effort.
The title
‘Disabled’
in Owen’s
poem
is one of the key
ways
in which the
central
character
is portrayed
.
The
adjective
tells
us that this
man
may be
disabled
in one or more
ways
, creating an
image
of
man
who
is
only
a shadow of his former self, and setting the tone for this
poem
, while
also
telling the reader what the
poem
is about.
The
title
also
begins
to introduce
some of the
major themes within the
poem
such as; loss, loneliness and helplessness, all of which the main
character
is feeling
because
of his disability.
Within the
first
stanza
the
poet
wrote that ‘He sat in a wheeled chair, waiting for
dark
. ’ The
use
of the pronoun ‘he’
shows
that the
man
is anonymous,
but
this may
also
be symbolic to
all of the
other young
men
who
came out of the
war
with less than they
started
with, and this
character
may be acting as a representative for the
many
who
lost
something
. The adjective ‘wheeled’
tells
the reader that the
man
cannot walk and this
brings
a
sense
of dependency, providing a tragic
image
of a
man
who
used
to be independent and is
now
bound to a chair for the rest of his
life
. The
phrase
‘waiting for
dark’
provides
another depressing
image
of a
man
who
has
lost
so
much that he can
only
feel
better
in the
dark
, when he is asleep, when he doesn’t
have to
think
about his problems or acknowledge them.
The
adjective
‘dark’
can
also
mean an
end
to
something
, in the
poem
it is the
end
of the day
that is
approaching,
but
maybe he
also
wants
his
life
to
end
.
In the second
line
the author
uses
the alliteration and plosives 'ghastly
suit
of
grey
’ to present a
ghostly
image
of the
man
in a
suit
that matches his appearance. The adjective ‘ghastly’ signifies death and wearing a ‘ghastly
suit
of
grey
’ may
also
be his plea for death. The adjective ‘
grey
’ illustrates a dull and lifeless
suit
which,
again
, could reflect how the
man
is
seen
, dull and lifeless.
After that, the
poet
provides
more of an
image
of the
man
who
the
poem
is about, ‘Legless, sewn short at elbow. ’ The adjective ‘legless’ depicts how the
man
looks and the comma afterwards
adds
emphasis onto the adjective beforehand, letting the reader digest that
image
and feel sympathy for the
man
and what he has
lost
. The
phrase
‘sewn short at elbow’ highlights another
part
of the
man’s
disability and the full
stop
at the
end
is in the middle of the
line
, causing a caesura which,
again
,
adds
emphasis onto the
man’s
disabilities, evoking feelings of sympathy from the reader. The caesura
also
shows
how his
life
has been
stopped
partway
through
,
just
like the line.
Then, the
poet
writes that
‘Voices
of
boys
rang saddening like a hymn,
’
which
really
underlines how sad, lonely and depressed the
man
is.
‘Voices
of
boys’
are supposed
to be joyful and uplifting, about the
youth
having fun,
but
in this
line
they are
part
of the simile
‘Voices
of
boys
rang saddening like a hymn’ which
shows
contrast between the
‘Voices
of
boys’
and the verb ‘saddening’. This may suggest that the
man
is sad hearing the
voices
of the
youth
playing as it reminds him of his past, what he no longer has and what he can no longer do.
In the
final
parts
of the
stanza
it
says
that
‘Voices
of play and pleasures after day, till gathering sleep mothered them from him’. The alliteration of ‘play and pleasures’
adds
an emphasis on these two words, reminding the reader and the
man
of what he can no longer do or have. The
phrase
‘till gathering sleep mothered them from him’ suggests that the children had to go home,
but
the
final
part
of the
phrase
‘from him’
shows
that they
must
have had
some
significance to him as he considers them
something
that he had, as if they were his
own
memories about his past and his
youth
before
his
life
changed
.
In the second
stanza
it
says
‘When the glow-lamps budded in the light-blue trees, ’. The verb ‘budded’ refers to the
youth
, and the
central
character's
youth
and the
phrase
‘light-blue trees’
uses
a calm and bright
colour
to
show
how his
life
was and how he was happy.
Later in the
stanza
it
says
‘In the
old
times
,
before
he threw away his knees. ’ The
time
phrase
‘In the
old
times’
contrasts what the
central
character
was able to do with what he can’t
now
. In the second
part
of the
line
the
poet
uses
the verb ‘threw’. This is making it seem like the
narrator
deliberately
threw away his knees and
provides
the reader with a
sense
of wastefulness
but
also
a large
sense
of regret, as if the soldier
was pressured
into the situation, which the reader finds out later in the poem.
To
end
the
stanza
it
says
that ‘All of them touch him like a queer disease. ’ The predeterminer ‘all’ is referring to everyone, not
just
the girls, and
shows
how the
central
character
is a pariah of
society
, where everyone avoids him and tries to interact with him as
little
as possible. The
phrase
‘touch him like a queer disease’
shows
how he
is treated
, with the adjective ‘queer’ meaning abnormal in this context and provokes a
sense
of pathos towards the
central
character
. The noun ‘disease’ suggests that what he has is infectious and can
be spread
, which could be why he
is isolated
as
people
don’t
want
to become what he has become.
Within the third
stanza
it
is written
that ‘He’s
lost
his
colour
very
far from here’. The verb
‘lost’
brings
a grim
image
and
shows
the horrors of
war
as one can lose lots on the battlefield and afterwards when it
says
‘his
colour
’ the noun ‘
colour
’ is a
reference
back
to the dull
grey
suit
in the
first
stanza
. It can
also
be referring to his personality, to his emotions, to himself, all
lost
in war.
The
central
part
of the
poem
depicts the youthful naivety of the
character
when in the fourth
stanza
the
narrator
says
that ‘Aye, that was it, to
please
the giddy jilts’. The
narrator
is showing us that the
central
character
was impressionable and swept up in the
war
effort and army.
The
‘giddy jilts’ are referring to girls and it could
be interpreted
that he is
easily
pressured into things.
The
verse size within the fifth
stanza
is smaller than the rest. This could be referring to how
many
people
thanked him or appreciated his service.
At the
very
end
of the
poem
there are
some
rhetorical
questions
‘How
cold
and late it is! … Why don’t they
come
? ’ This could be the
voice
of Owen, and it is like he is talking to the nurses. It
shows
how the
central
character
is
marginalised
and outcast, with no one wanting to
help
him. The
phrase
‘Why don’t they
come
and put him to bed? ’ links
back
to the
first
line
, as both are suggesting death and how he is waiting for it
so
that his suffering can
end
.
Throughout the
poem
, the
use
of
colour
is structured
around the
poem
, telling us about the atmosphere in the stanzas where it
is mentioned
.
For example
, ‘
grey
’ is
used
within the
first
stanza
to
provide
imagery for a deathly
man
, while in the second
stanza
‘light blue’ is
used
to
provide
a happy and bright image.
Within the title, ‘
Still
I
Rise’
the reader can
see
that this
poem
will
be written
in the
first
person from the pronoun ‘I’. The entire
phrase
is a declaration and
shows
an
image
of a powerful
narrator
who
is
strong
and resilient. The
phrase
also
sets the theme for the
poem
, where the
narrator
will
rise
against the problems that she faces and overcome them. This is
also
a declaration against
prejudice
which Angelou experienced throughout her life.
The main
character
, portrayed by the
first
person, is the
poet
, Angelou, and
is shown
as a
strong
, powerful and proud woman
who
wants
to overcome the inequalities and
prejudices
in the world to
make
it a
better
and more equal place.
At the
end
of the
first
stanza
the
narrator
says
‘You may
trod
me in the dirt,
but
still
, like dust, I’ll
rise’
. The active verb ‘trod’
brings
the
image
of the
poet
being stepped
on
metaphorically
and
provides
an understanding of suppression and repression
but
the simile afterwards ‘
still
, like dust, I’ll
rise
. ’ opposes this statement and
shows
that Angelou
is determined
to not
be held
back
and
wants
to reach to the skies. The full
stop
at the
end
of the
stanza
also
creates a pause on the verb
‘rise’
which
emphasises
the hopeful and successful meaning of the
word
and the
word
used
with the pronoun ‘I’ reflects the
positive
meaning onto the author.
After this Angelou
uses
a simile, ‘‘
Cause I
walk like I’ve
got
oil wells pumping in my living room. ’ ‘Oil wells’ are a symbol of wealth, and at that
time
, white wealth. This goes against the stereotypes and
shows
how she is opening up new possibilities that may have
been restricted
for
people
like her. It
also
refers to richness, such as her richness of confidence and her richness of personality.
Angelou
uses
references
to
nature
in describing how she will overcome the
prejudice
, “
Just
like moons and like suns with the certainty of tides. ”
Nature
is
seen
as
something
that happens, and cannot be
stopped
, and she is calling herself like
‘nature’
and cannot be
stopped
. This can
also
be
seen
through
the similes “
Just
like moons and like suns” as ‘moons’ and ‘suns’ cannot be
stopped
. Angelou is
also
saying that she is ‘certain’ she will
rise
when she
says
“With the certainty of tides,
”
which
again
refers to
nature
and how
nature
will
rise
,
just
like
nature
will act. This whole
stanza
portrays her confidence as
strong
, powerful and simple,
just
like nature.
Within the fourth
stanza
more serious and disturbing themes
are spoken
of with Angelou using
rhetorical
questions
which
reference
to slavery. “Did you
want
to
see
me broken? Bowed head and lowered eyes? ” These
rhetorical
questions
seem sassy and mocking as if Angelou is telling the audience that those things will never happen to her. These
rhetorical
questions
are
also
criticising
white
people
, and all that they have done to black
people
and slaves, by providing an
image
of submission in the
question
, which is
predominantly
aimed at white
people
who
thought
they were superior.
She then
uses
violent verbs and anaphora to talk about what
people
may do to her. “You may shoot me with your words,
”
which
reference
the attitudes towards black
people
in her
time
and how they
were belittled
and trodden on. These
first
three
lines
are
also
portraying the vulnerabilities of everybody and how this violence has been
used
to
make
black
people
suffer. Angelou finishes off the
stanza
with the simile “
But
still
, like air, I’ll
rise
. ” This
shows
how
strong
she is and how confident she is that she will overcome that
prejudice
. The structure of the
stanza
shows
the resilience of Angelou
and others
like her
who
have suffered, and how, no matter what
bad
things happen, they will always
rise
back
up and confront it, no matter how
hard
it is.
Within the structure of the
poem
there are
rhetorical
questions
which present features of herself, “Does my
sassiness
upset you? ” There are another
two
with “haughtiness” and “sexiness”. These nouns
show
that Angelou is confident in herself and when she asks if they “upset you? ” She is showing that she can be whatever she
wants
and doesn’t
have to
listen to anybody else.
Within the
final
two stanzas she
uses
an
AABB
rhyme scheme to create a
strong
tempo to
bring
the
piece
to a climax while
also
reflecting herself as a
strong
and steady woman, in
reference
to the tempo and rhythm of the
piece
. Angelou has
changed
the structure of the Stanzas from an
ABCB
, to the stronger and more rhythmic
AABB
rhyme scheme to
show
how she is breaking
through
suppression and becoming an unstoppable force that will break
through
prejudice
, coming out as free and equal.
At the
end
of the penultimate
stanza
she
references
nature
again
in the metaphor “I’m a black ocean, leading and wide, welling and swelling I bear in the tide. ” The “black ocean” is a
way
of saying that she cannot be
stopped
as she is an immense force and anything in her
way
will not affect her path towards her goal.
Also
the active words “leading”, “wide”, “welling” and “swelling”
show
all that she is doing to achieve her goal, and
also
how much effort she has put into this.
She
ends
the
final
stanza
and the
poem
with anaphora of the
phrase
“I
rise”
. This
emphasises
what she is going to do and achieve and the repetition of the
phrase
reinforces the
idea
that she will
rise
above the
prejudice
and inequality, making her more confident about achieving her goal.
I chose these two texts
because
of the
way
they conveyed
strong
messages and comments about
society
. I chose the
pieces
‘Disabled’
and ‘
Still
I
Rise’
as they explore how extreme we, as a
society
, can be towards those
who
are
different
,
but
also
how we can
rise
up and
stop
this.
‘Disabled’
evoked a feeling of sorrow within, for
all of the
people
affected
by
war
, while ‘
Still
I
Rise’
showed
me a fiery intent to
make
the world a
better
place. Although there were other
pieces
of work such as ‘The Bright Lights of Sarajevo’ which
showed
the positivity of
society
and how we can overcome hardship, ‘Out, Out -’ which
showed
how we have become almost numb to violence and death in the media and ‘The Necklace’ which
shows
how materialistic desires have taken over society.
‘Disabled’
shows
how we treat those
who
have
given
their
life
for us and that
society
will
only
accept those deemed acceptable,
otherwise
they shall
be cast
out. It
is written
in the third person in the perspective of an unknown soldier
who
served in World
War
One and
lost
his limbs and “
colour
” there. It talks about after the
war
when he is outcast for his condition and about how he gave up his
life
for his country.
In
contrast
‘
Still
I
Rise’
has a message of hope and confidence in the future that everybody will be equal. It is about the writer, Maya Angelou, and
is set
in a
time
of great racism and inequality in America. The
poem
talks about Angelou, her qualities which she is proud of, and how she will overcome societal norms and become a free and equal black woman
who
can stand up for herself to form a
better
place for
people
suffering from
prejudice
.